Generator 21 masthead. COVER -> MEMOIRS OF THE INFORMATION AGE
A spaceholder

ISPAM At-Large

by Bob Martin

To read this article in Deutsch, Francaise, Italiano, Portuguese, Espanol and not English, copy and paste the complete URL("http://www.g21.net/mem34.html") and enter it in the box after you click through.

I followed the advice given by Rod Amis in his IT Manager's Journal column and decided to sign up as an At-Large member of the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN.) On Friday I received a message saying that I and 12,000 people had been accepted. They said that they would send me my personal idenfication number (PIN.) On Saturday my e-mail box started being bombarded with spam from the other 12,000 members.

I will give it to Mr. Amis that over time he has both criticized ICANN's operations and also gone to the trouble to interview it's Board Chairman, Ms. Esther Dyson, here at G21. But the fact remains that, by following his advice to take part in the dialogue about the future of the Internet and the Web, I became victim to another ICANN screw-up. I am being spammed.

Half the people spamming me are taking the attitude of "I'm in contact with a new international community! Let's all talk to each other."

I can understand this, but I also believe that I should be able to *choose* which community I am part of, which is not what is happening in this instance. Simply because I signed up to be an At-Large member of ICANN doesn't mean I want to be part of a new mailing list. Ask me first, please!

"All the evidence is there: ICANN can't. Network Solutions was bad, but this is chaos"


A space holder.

A space holder.
"Yeah, I could easily solve that problem for you... But what's in it for me?"
The World's Magazine: g21.net

Event # 211: SINK OR SHRINK


This Pull-down Menu will hyperjump you to all our great features. Try it!

JOIN THE G21 MAILING LIST. Get updates on new features. Take part in our Readership polls, shape the future of The World's Magazine. It's easy! E-mail The World's Magazine with the "Subject" line: SUBSCRIBE.

Want to know more about our community? The Info is here.



LAST WEEK's EDITION


For Deep Background visit the G21-Barnes & Noble Shop

OR get great books at the G21 BARNES & NOBLE SEARCH ENGINE

HOME


Discover the MOIA Discussion List


A space holder.

Memoirs graphic.

The other half of the people are just like me. They are asking people to restrain from spamming us without our permission. They are asking people to *not* reply to the list. And they are writing angry letters to ICANN asking them to delete their name from the At-Large membership mailing list. I have not done that, but I was tempted to on Saturday as my mailbox continuing to ring with those infernal messages.

I am writing this to the G21 because it's Mr. Amis' Web magazine and I hope that he will show the grace of allowing me to write about a mistake he made in giving his reserved endorsement to ICANN's efforts.

I'm also writing this because I am a businessman and citizen involved with the Internet daily. I am concerned about the future of Internet and want to believe that by taking part in citizen adminstration of this new medium and its affect on the new economy I can help stave off governmental interference.

It is not that I am anti-government. I am not. My concern is that people who actually understand technology, the Internet, and the new economy regulate it rather than bureaucrats and politicians who have other, and often misguided agendas.

So taking part in programs like ICANN At-Large membership seemed to me at the time to be the right thing to do.

Today, I have concerns and more reservations. Today I see this spam attack as another evidence of government darlings, with the support of the United States Department of Commerce, beginning a new program without forethought! I never should have been spammed. Somebody somewhere among the members of the At-Large program team should have foreseen this problem. That they didn't makes me angry.

I do think there should be some committee, or working group, that allows those of us who use the Internet to conduct our business to dialogue about its future.

I also believe that it should be a bottom-up and not a top-down structure. My idea scenario is that we model it on the collaborative efforts of the Open Source movement. I believe that can work for us.

But, now more than ever, I am troubled with how ICANN does business.

My hope is that by sending this message to Mr. Amis and G21 the magazine will make an effort to contact ICANN officials and have them speak with us publically about this latest fiasco.

At the very least, I'm hoping that this e-mail will be published for other technology professionals to read.

Every week in "Memoirs of the Information," this magazine encourages us to "Take the Risk of Involvement." Well, I did and I got burned.

I want to believe that this situation will be addressed.



TAKE THE RISK OF INVOLVEMENT.



g21.net The World's Magazine



You can watch history...
or make it.


A space holder.



Meet the new Boss...





MEMOIRS OF THE INFORMATION AGE ARCHIVES

THE PREVIOUS MEMOIR

THE NEXT MEMOIR




+++ Home +++ RECOMMENDED +++

© 2000, GENERATOR 21.

E-mail your comments. We always like to hear from you. Send your kudos, brickbats and suggestions to rod@g21.net.