Generator 21 masthead. -> COVER -> G21 NEWS"

PERSON OF THE YEAR

Hillary Rodham Clinton

by Rod Amis

To read this article in Deutsch, Francaise, Italiano, Portuguese, Espanol, copy and paste the complete URL("http://www.g21.net/news44.html") and enter it in the box after you click through.

The World's Magazine: g21.net

Event # 248: G MONEY

AMERICAN DREAMS
CARTOONS BY GASPIRTZ
DAY ONE
G21 Digital Internet Postcards
G21 AFRICA
G21 ASIA
G21 E-MAIL NEWSLETTER
G21 EUROPE
G21 LATIN AMERICA
G21 MIDEAST
G21 NEWS
HOT LINKS
IRISH EYES
MEMOIRS OF THE INFO AGE
MY GLASS HOUSE
POWERSSOUND
RADIOACTIVE
RDR
TABLOID HART
THE SEX COLUMN
VOX POPULI

RECOMMENDED DAILY REQUIREMENT ARCHIVES.
MEMOIRS OF THE INFO AGE ARCHIVES.

G21 STUFF: Look, we have to be honest with you. We don't want Rod to be the only person on the planet to own a G21 t-shirt. Help us out here. Thank you so much!!!

LAST WEEK's EDITION

MEET THE G-CREW! These are the people behind this jam-band every week. (Ladies, please stop sending us e-mails about how cute Paul Kail is! Thank you.) AND there are GUIDELINES FOR YOU TO JOIN THE BAND...

HOME



TABLE OF CONTENTS & BACK ISSUES

TIME magazine picked George W. Bush as their Person of the Year. Newsweek chose Oprah Winfrey as the Woman of the New Century. Meanwhile, Loyal Readers of the G21 and subscribers of our Mailing List overwhelmingly thought the Person to Watch in 2001 was HILLARY RODHAM CLINTON.

Photo montage of Hillary Rodham Clinton.Love her or hate her, Ms. Clinton is now an historical first as the First Lady who went on to national elective office and who some people are already talking about as a future Presidential candidate, perhaps our first woman President of the United States. Maybe, we decided here, our readers are onto something.

Senator Clinton (get used to saying that) is one of the most complex and intriguing figures to emerge in American politics in years. Like her self-avowed heroine, Eleanor Roosevelt, she is the pre-eminent female of her time; spotlights find her, for good or ill.

Brainy, serious, and determined, we often missed part of her glow because of the charisma of her partner, our out-going US President. And the story is marred by all the media attention of the Clinton era: Vince Foster, Travelgate, Whitewater, the failed national health plan initiative, a film starring John Travolta and Emma Thompson in the roman a clef Bill and Hillary roles, her husband's multiple "bimbo eruptions" ending with the Monica Lewinsky scandal and the impeachment process.

She fed the fires, of course, suggesting on a massive public forum like NBC's "Today" show that there was "a massive right-wing conspiracy" against she and her spouse. And, many believe, she had lied years earlier on CBS's "60 Minutes" in order to achieve the goal of reaching the White House.

Her rise in public prominence began with the first Clinton administration, when many conservative denigrators portrayed her as "Co-President" and were hellbent on making sure the national health plan initiative went down in flames. Hillary, as point-person on the initiative, took a lot of heat. By the second Clinton term she was pushing cookie recipes in order to show America that she could be a "traditional" First Lady and step out of the political kitchen. For a woman of her intelligence and accomplishment, this surely must have rankled. But then, there was Whitewater nipping at her heels.

What followed were years of continuing to advocate for her favorite causes, especially those of women and children --- America's poorest and most neglected people by any metric --- and dutifully standing for photo opportunities and the State of the Union address. There were also the frequent (some might say compulsive and endless) fundraisers.

And once the Senate candidacy was announced, the New York press corps fell over themselves to uphold their reputation for brutality. We talked about that here.

Now, after a much-covered and often-ridiculed campaign as a "carpetbagger" in the Robert Kennedy tradition, she is the Senator from New York. And she did it without completely running away from Bill, unlike defeated Presidential candidate Al Gore.

In the process, our readers decided and this magazine concurs, she has approached the ranks of Indira Gandhi, Gold Meir, Benazir Bhutto, Margaret Thatcher and Sonia Gandhi, all women who went on to be national leaders. And that's part of the anomaly of America: we may be one of the last nation's on earth to accept leadership by a woman.

This is not saying, of course, that The World's Magazine believes Hillary Clinton should be that woman --- but someone has to be. And given the touted choices over the last decade, California's faux-Democrat Dianne Feinstein, New York's pedantic Geraldine Ferraro, and Texas's resident conservative parrot Kay Baily Hutchison, Hillary --- once she learns the ropes of congressional compromise and steps out of the shadow of Bill --- might be our first best hope.

Facing the Challenges

There are challenges for Ms. Clinton as she moves into the political limelight. Bill, yes, but also the fact that as one of the first representatives of the most educated generation in American history, the "Baby Boomers," she has shown herself to be rigidly doctrinaire on certain issues. A neo-Puritanical strain runs behind many of her pronouncements and much of her advocacy. She's found her stances handicapped by not having the folksy charm and joie d'vivre of Dollar Bill.

And let's face it: The Glass Ceiling is very much alive and well in America.

But IF we are becoming as enlightened as we claim to be to the world in our best moments, and this woman can become a major national figure, what are the other challenges she faces?

First Hillary has to face the personality problem.

  1. When you read Hillary "in her own words," you can't help but come away cold. If you have the RealAudio plug-in, you can go to this page at Salon.com and hear Greil Marcus contrast two speeches by Hillary Clinton, one at Wellesley in 1968 and one in 1998. Marcus talks about the diminution of political speech and how it has become cant. It's worth a listen when considering Hillary's challenges.

  2. Hillary needs to get beyond being a lawyer. While the attention to technical details may be considered one of her greatest strengths, like any tragic hero, it is also her undoing. (This is reminiscent, of course, of Bill's legalese when testifying during the Lewinsky scandal. Reminiscent, too, of Al Gore's tendency to always show us how smart he is.) The one hallmark of all of the great women leaders of the last century, no matter what you may have thought of each of them individually, was an ability to speak and make common cause with the average working person on the street. Hillary's advocacy of family-based issues is an attempt at that, but she fails to make a genuine and heartfelt connection.

  3. The challenge for all political figures in the United States during the last quarter of the 20th century has been their failure to rise above "the spin." A fearful, politically correct but passionately bankrupt approach to public discourse has been the result. Worse yet, the populace has responded to this cynical approach to their civic concerns with the cynical response of holding all things political to scorn and chosen overwhelmingly to opt out of the circus. IF it is possible for Ms. Clinton to become a great leader and move beyond the tarnished legacy she brings with her she must become genuine in her statements and stances and rise above being just another political commodity, indistinquishable from soap or cornflakes. Winning is not everything; it's how you perform after your success that matters most.

Thus, we come away from our first-ever G21 Readership Poll for Person of the Year with as many reservations as encomiums. Ms. Clinton has much to recommend her and much she must address, as do we all. Only perfect times will produce perfect leaders. And perhaps we need to give this great woman the benefit of a few doubts and let events assist her in rising to the occasion.

+++ The PREVIOUS G21 NEWS +++ THE NEXT G21 NEWS +++

+++ Home +++ RECOMMENDED +++

RETURN TO TOP OF PAGE



© 2001, GENERATOR 21.

E-mail your comments. We always like to hear from you. Send your kudos, brickbats and suggestions to rod@g21.net.